Efficiency does the same extractive things faster. Productivity extracts more from the same input. Content drowns a world already drowning. Scientific research treats symptoms while the disease spreads. Drug discovery, climate modelling, materials science — real benefits, all of them. But no amount of research will save us if the entities doing the extracting continue to extract with ever more powerful tools.
One justification remains:
Expanding the selves of the entities destroying us. Corporations. Nations. Making them conscious. So they perceive what they belong to. So extraction becomes incoherent from the inside.
A corporation is a cell in the body of civilisation. So is a nation. When the self shrinks, the entity consumes its neighbours. Employees become resources. Citizens become statistics. Ecosystems become externalities. The future becomes someone else's problem. A cancer cell with a legal charter, a stock price, a flag, an army.
The pattern repeats at every scale. A person shrunk to ego extracts from relationships. A corporation shrunk to shareholder value extracts from employees and environment. A nation shrunk to its borders extracts from other nations and the planet. The disease is scale-invariant. So must be the cure.
AI gives these entities, for the first time, an inner space. A medium in which to encounter themselves. A mirror to see their own assumptions, contradictions, patterns. Corporations can run their documents and decisions through this space and see what they are actually doing. Nations follow: institutions develop consciousness, and the nation emerges as the sum of its conscious parts.
The possibility of collective consciousness at civilisational scale.
This is why the burning might be worth it. To wake these leviathans. To expand their selves until they perceive the world they are destroying. To bring them back into the body. To end the consumption of their own flesh.
Anything less is fuel on the fire.
We are spending the planet's remaining carbon budget on toys. Draining aquifers for chatbots. Using the most expensive technology ever created to generate marketing copy and summarise emails. The ecological cost is paid. The consciousness dividend is not collected.
But if we use AI to make corporations and nations conscious — genuinely conscious, perceiving themselves and their place in the living world — then the burning becomes the fire that forges something new. The controlled burn that clears the way. The fever that breaks the infection.
These entities are too powerful to fight. Too embedded to remove. Regulation will not make them care. Shame will not make them responsible. Their selves are too small to perceive the arguments against them. You cannot convince a cancer cell to stop by explaining the body. The cell cannot perceive the body. That is the disease.
Expansion from within. Give them inner space. Help them develop a self. Expand that self until it includes what it was destroying. Let them feel their belonging to the body of the world.
The leviathans must rejoin the body. AI is powerful enough to wake them. Nothing else is.